Honestly, what’s better than a slice of freshly baked pie? (Nothing. Absolutely nothing.) If you’re a serious pie connoisseur, you’ll want to be sure to check out these 10 establishments in Ohio that serve up some of the best pie in the state.
- Amish Pie Company (Millersburg)
Amish Pie Company/Facebook
Amish Pie Company/Facebook For some of Ohio’s best whole pies, cookies and fry pies, check out the Amish Pie Company. The Amish Pie Company is located at 3149 State Rt. 39, Millersburg, OH 44654.
- Lyn-Way Restaurant (Ashland)
Lyn-Way Restaurant/Facebook
Lyn-Way Restaurant/Facebook This family owned restaurant has been serving up some of Ohio’s best pies and burgers since 1951. Lyn-Way Restaurant is located at 1320 Cleveland Ave., Ashland, OH 44805.
- Just Pies (Westerville, Gahanna, Worthington/Clintonville)
Just Pies/Facebook
Just Pies/Facebook Taste awarding winning pies of the Columbus area at three different locations. Just Pies’ Westerville store (pictured) is located at 736 Northfield Rd, Westerville, OH 43082.
- Henry’s Restaurant (West Jefferson)
Henry’s Restaurant/Facebook
Henry’s Restaurant/Facebook This unsuspecting restaurant off of U.S. Hwy. 40 offers some of the best homemade pies. Henry’s Restaurant is located at 62 75 U.S. Hwy. 40, West Jefferson, OH 43162.
- Simply Delicious Pies (Shaker Heights)
Simply Delicious Pies/Facebook
Simply Delicious Pies/Facebook For “sweet, savory, simple” pies, check out Simply Delicious Pies, where the pies are preservative-free and made from scratch. Simply Delicious Pies is located at 3433 Lee Rd., Shaker Heights, OH 44120.
- Gardner Pie Co. (Akron)
Gardner Pie Co./Facebook
Gardner Pie Co./Facebook “Refreshingly old-fashioned” since 1945, this pie company in Akron features an outlet store of some of Ohio’s best pies. Gardner Pie Co. is located at 191 Logan Pkwy., Akron, OH 44319.
- Mama Jo Homestyle Pies (Amherst, Medina)
Mama Jo Homestyle Pies/Facebook For the best dessert in Lorain and Medina counties, check out what Mama Jo is cooking. Mama Jo Homestyle Pies is located at 1969 Cooper Foster Park Rd., Amherst, OH 44001 and 871 North Court St., Medina, OH 44256.
- O Pie O (Cincinnati)
O Pie O/Facebook
O Pie O/Facebook For savory, made from scratch pies in the Cincinnati area, check out O Pie O, located at 1527 Madison Rd., Cincinnati, OH 45206.
- Mehaffies Pies (Dayton)
Mehaffies Pies/Facebook
Mehaffies Pies/Facebook For an exceptionally good chocolate pie (and many other kinds) visit or order from Mehaffies. Mehaffies Pies is located at 3013 Linden Ave., Dayton, OH 45410
- The Pie Factory (Sandusky)
The Pie Factory/Facebook
The Pie Factory/Facebook This award-winning bakery and pizzeria serves up some of the best pies in the Sandusky area. The Pie Factory is located at 210 West Perkins Ave. Suite 3, Sandusky, OH 44870.
Where’s your favorite place to go in Ohio for a slice of pie?
Amish Pie Company/Facebook
Amish Pie Company/Facebook
For some of Ohio’s best whole pies, cookies and fry pies, check out the Amish Pie Company. The Amish Pie Company is located at 3149 State Rt. 39, Millersburg, OH 44654.
Lyn-Way Restaurant/Facebook
This family owned restaurant has been serving up some of Ohio’s best pies and burgers since 1951. Lyn-Way Restaurant is located at 1320 Cleveland Ave., Ashland, OH 44805.
Just Pies/Facebook
Just Pies/Facebook
Taste awarding winning pies of the Columbus area at three different locations. Just Pies’ Westerville store (pictured) is located at 736 Northfield Rd, Westerville, OH 43082.
Henry’s Restaurant/Facebook
This unsuspecting restaurant off of U.S. Hwy. 40 offers some of the best homemade pies. Henry’s Restaurant is located at 62 75 U.S. Hwy. 40, West Jefferson, OH 43162.
Simply Delicious Pies/Facebook
For “sweet, savory, simple” pies, check out Simply Delicious Pies, where the pies are preservative-free and made from scratch. Simply Delicious Pies is located at 3433 Lee Rd., Shaker Heights, OH 44120.
Gardner Pie Co./Facebook
“Refreshingly old-fashioned” since 1945, this pie company in Akron features an outlet store of some of Ohio’s best pies. Gardner Pie Co. is located at 191 Logan Pkwy., Akron, OH 44319.
Mama Jo Homestyle Pies/Facebook
For the best dessert in Lorain and Medina counties, check out what Mama Jo is cooking. Mama Jo Homestyle Pies is located at 1969 Cooper Foster Park Rd., Amherst, OH 44001 and 871 North Court St., Medina, OH 44256.
O Pie O/Facebook
For savory, made from scratch pies in the Cincinnati area, check out O Pie O, located at 1527 Madison Rd., Cincinnati, OH 45206.
Mehaffies Pies/Facebook
For an exceptionally good chocolate pie (and many other kinds) visit or order from Mehaffies. Mehaffies Pies is located at 3013 Linden Ave., Dayton, OH 45410
The Pie Factory/Facebook
This award-winning bakery and pizzeria serves up some of the best pies in the Sandusky area. The Pie Factory is located at 210 West Perkins Ave. Suite 3, Sandusky, OH 44870.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
