Seafood isn’t for everyone. For the most part, it seems like you either love it or you hate it. I’ve never really met anyone who was just “alright” with eating seafood. If you happen to enjoy it, you might be wondering where you can get a nice tasty slab of fish in the state of Indiana. What restaurants in Indiana have the best seafood ever? Well, I did some digging and pulled together a nice list.
- Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market and Restaurant
Brittany S. via yelp.com
From their website. The Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market and Restaurant lives by the motto of “bringing the best of the sea of Indy.” Did you know this restaurant was voted #1 in the state of Indiana on both Movoto and Yelp? Apparently, you can’t get a better fish sandwich than the one you get at this state. The restaurant receives daily deliveries of the freshest seafood in the state. Whether you are coming to enjoy something they cook or you want to get something to make at home, this is a great place to go. 7460 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis
- Lighthouse Restaurant
From their website.
From their website. Customers consider this to be a gem in the northwestern portion of the state of Indiana. Reservations are not required to dine at this eatery, but making a reservation is highly recommended to ensure you get a good seat. From bacon wrapped scallops to buffalo shrimp, you can get just about any delicious seafood you could want. They even have a wide range of steaks and other types of meat. This makes it easy to bring a loved one who doesn’t like seafood with you. 7501 Constitution Ave, Cedar Lake
- UMI Sushi & Lounge
Jeremy H. via yelp.com
Alex B. via yelp.com UMI Sushi & Lounge has been serving both innovative and traditional Japanese cuisine to the area since the year 2007. The starfish sushi roll is one of the featured items on the menu and highly recommended to anyone who enjoys sushi and seafood. 109 W Joliet St, Crown Point
- Clarksville Seafood
From their website.
Diane R. via yelp.com Clarksville Seafood is a family-run seafood eatery with baskets of oysters, fried shrimp, and fresh fish just waiting to be enjoyed. 916 Eastern Blvd, Clarksville
- Mitchell’s Fish Market
Tom B. via yelp.com
Anna O. via yelp.com Mitchell’s Fish Market is considered to be a casual upscale seafood eatery. A wide range of seafood dishes as well as some tasty happy hour martinis are waiting for you to enjoy them at this establishment. 14311 Clay Terrace Blvd, Carmel
- Theo’s Steaks & Seafood
Pete K. via yelp.com
Pete K. via yelp.com Theo’s Steaks & Seafood is a classic steakhouse that offers a fine dining experience. It has a lively atmosphere and extremely friendly customer service. From prime rib to seafood, this is a great place to eat. The selection of meat on the menu makes it perfect for families to go when some like seafood and others do not. 9144 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland
- Formosa Seafood Buffet
Chyna M. via yelp.com
Erica K. via yelp.com Are you interested in eating seafood until you’re stuffed? This is a large and elegant seafood buffet in Indianapolis. Most customers agree the size of the buffet is pretty impressive considering how expensive quality seafood can usually be. 6304 E 82nd St, Indianapolis
- Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar
Kevin. K. via yelp.com
Scott T. via yelp.com Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar is home to both tropical and Asian delights. All of the seafood and sushi within this eatery features a tropic theme. There is a fish market attached if you want to buy some fish to take home with you as well. 310 Eastlake Dr, Warsaw
- Chubby Trout
From their Facebook page.
From their Facebook page. Chubby Trout is home to delicious hand breaded Cajun fish nibblers, calamari fingers, and incredible citrus tartar sauce. 2730 Cassopolis St, Elkhart
- Kona Jack’s Fish Market & Sushi Bar
Angela T. via yelp.com
Cara S. via yelp.com A fish market, a sushi bar, and live music entertainment are just waiting for you! Did you know this restaurant is considered to be one of the top seafood restaurants in Indianapolis? This particular eatery has a Hawaiian theme. 9413 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis
Brittany S. via yelp.com
From their website.
The Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market and Restaurant lives by the motto of “bringing the best of the sea of Indy.” Did you know this restaurant was voted #1 in the state of Indiana on both Movoto and Yelp? Apparently, you can’t get a better fish sandwich than the one you get at this state. The restaurant receives daily deliveries of the freshest seafood in the state. Whether you are coming to enjoy something they cook or you want to get something to make at home, this is a great place to go. 7460 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis
Customers consider this to be a gem in the northwestern portion of the state of Indiana. Reservations are not required to dine at this eatery, but making a reservation is highly recommended to ensure you get a good seat. From bacon wrapped scallops to buffalo shrimp, you can get just about any delicious seafood you could want. They even have a wide range of steaks and other types of meat. This makes it easy to bring a loved one who doesn’t like seafood with you. 7501 Constitution Ave, Cedar Lake
Jeremy H. via yelp.com
Alex B. via yelp.com
UMI Sushi & Lounge has been serving both innovative and traditional Japanese cuisine to the area since the year 2007. The starfish sushi roll is one of the featured items on the menu and highly recommended to anyone who enjoys sushi and seafood. 109 W Joliet St, Crown Point
Diane R. via yelp.com
Clarksville Seafood is a family-run seafood eatery with baskets of oysters, fried shrimp, and fresh fish just waiting to be enjoyed. 916 Eastern Blvd, Clarksville
Tom B. via yelp.com
Anna O. via yelp.com
Mitchell’s Fish Market is considered to be a casual upscale seafood eatery. A wide range of seafood dishes as well as some tasty happy hour martinis are waiting for you to enjoy them at this establishment. 14311 Clay Terrace Blvd, Carmel
Pete K. via yelp.com
Theo’s Steaks & Seafood is a classic steakhouse that offers a fine dining experience. It has a lively atmosphere and extremely friendly customer service. From prime rib to seafood, this is a great place to eat. The selection of meat on the menu makes it perfect for families to go when some like seafood and others do not. 9144 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland
Chyna M. via yelp.com
Erica K. via yelp.com
Are you interested in eating seafood until you’re stuffed? This is a large and elegant seafood buffet in Indianapolis. Most customers agree the size of the buffet is pretty impressive considering how expensive quality seafood can usually be. 6304 E 82nd St, Indianapolis
Kevin. K. via yelp.com
Scott T. via yelp.com
Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar is home to both tropical and Asian delights. All of the seafood and sushi within this eatery features a tropic theme. There is a fish market attached if you want to buy some fish to take home with you as well. 310 Eastlake Dr, Warsaw
From their Facebook page.
Chubby Trout is home to delicious hand breaded Cajun fish nibblers, calamari fingers, and incredible citrus tartar sauce. 2730 Cassopolis St, Elkhart
Angela T. via yelp.com
Cara S. via yelp.com
A fish market, a sushi bar, and live music entertainment are just waiting for you! Did you know this restaurant is considered to be one of the top seafood restaurants in Indianapolis? This particular eatery has a Hawaiian theme. 9413 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis
What do you think about these restaurants in Indiana? Have you ever enjoyed seafood at any of them before? Share your thoughts with me in the comments and let me know if you think there is a restaurant I should have included and didn’t!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
