Pie is great year-round, but I always think of it as a winter dessert. These 13 places in Utah have fabulous pies – check them out!
I compiled this list based on online review sites. It’s offered here alphabetically – not a ranking
- Arshel’s Cafe, Beaver
Arshel’s Cafe/Facebook
Arshel’s Cafe/Facebook Yelp reviewers rave about the pies here. 711 N. Main Street, Beaver
- Croshaw’s Gourmet Pies, St. George
Crowshaw’s/Facebook
Crowshaw’s/Facebook Huge gourmet pies at great prices. 175 W. 900 S., St. George.
- The Dodo Restaurant
The Dodo Restaurant/Facebook
The Dodo Restaurant/Facebook Famous for their Tollhouse Pie. 1355 E. 2100 S., Salt Lake City.
- Fillings and Emulsions, Salt Lake City
Fillings and Emulsions
Fillings and Emulsions/Facebook These aren’t just pies - they’re works of art. 25 East Kensington Ave., Salt Lake City.
- June Pie, Heber
June Pies/Facebook
June Pies/Facebook The pot pies look as tasty as the desserts! Open from 4-6 pm, Tuesday through Friday. 133 N. Main Street, Heber.
- Lehi Bakery, Lehi
Lehi Bakery/Facebook
Lehi Bakery Home of the square donut! 172 West Main St, Lehi
- Lion House Pantry, Salt Lake City
Lion House Pantry/Facebook
Lion House Pantry/Facebook Lion House has long been famous for its rolls and pies. 63 E. South Temple, Salt Lake City.
- Magleby’s Restaurant, Springville
Magleby’s/Facebook
Facebook/Magleby’s The chocolate cake at Magleby’s is amazing…but the pies are excellent too. Maybe get both? 198 S. Main, Springville.
- Penny Ann’s Cafe, SLC
Penny Ann’s Cafe/Facebook
Penny Ann’s Cafe/Facebook Penny Ann’s won Best of State for its breakfast this year, but its pies are also to die for. 1810 S. Main, Salt Lake City.
- Provo Bakery, Provo
Provo Bakery/Facebook
Provo Bakery/Facebook Go for the pies, but pick up some glazed doughnuts while you’re there. 190 E. 100 N., Provo
- Sunglow Cafe, Bicknell
Sunglow Cafe/Facebook
Sunglow Cafe/Facebook Yelp! reviewers rave about the pies in this little cafe in Bicknell. 92 E. Main, Bicknell.
- Thunderbird Restaurant, Mt. Carmel
Thunderbird Restaurant/Facebook
Thunderbird Restaurant/Facebook “Ho-made” pie. The sign for this restaurant is priceless. It started when the owner tried to squeeze the whole name onto his sign by shortening the word “home.” At the time, it didn’t have the same sexy connotation. Regardless, the pie is delicious. Try the apple pie with rum sauce. US-89, Mt. Carmel.
- Veyo Pies
Veyo Pies/Facebook
Veyo Pies/Facebook While this list is alphabetical and NOT a ranking, if it was, Veyo Pies would get the award for the Best Pie in the Entire State of Utah. It’s a tiny little shop, in an even tinier little town (Veyo has less than 500 residents). The pies are all completely hand-made, and so good that people drive from all over the state to get them. During holiday season, the shop sells around 100 pies per day. Banana Creme is the favorite.
Where is your favorite place for pie?
Arshel’s Cafe/Facebook
Yelp reviewers rave about the pies here. 711 N. Main Street, Beaver
Crowshaw’s/Facebook
Huge gourmet pies at great prices. 175 W. 900 S., St. George.
The Dodo Restaurant/Facebook
Famous for their Tollhouse Pie. 1355 E. 2100 S., Salt Lake City.
Fillings and Emulsions
Fillings and Emulsions/Facebook
These aren’t just pies - they’re works of art. 25 East Kensington Ave., Salt Lake City.
June Pies/Facebook
The pot pies look as tasty as the desserts! Open from 4-6 pm, Tuesday through Friday. 133 N. Main Street, Heber.
Lehi Bakery/Facebook
Lehi Bakery
Home of the square donut! 172 West Main St, Lehi
Lion House Pantry/Facebook
Lion House has long been famous for its rolls and pies. 63 E. South Temple, Salt Lake City.
Magleby’s/Facebook
Facebook/Magleby’s
The chocolate cake at Magleby’s is amazing…but the pies are excellent too. Maybe get both? 198 S. Main, Springville.
Penny Ann’s Cafe/Facebook
Penny Ann’s won Best of State for its breakfast this year, but its pies are also to die for. 1810 S. Main, Salt Lake City.
Provo Bakery/Facebook
Go for the pies, but pick up some glazed doughnuts while you’re there. 190 E. 100 N., Provo
Sunglow Cafe/Facebook
Yelp! reviewers rave about the pies in this little cafe in Bicknell. 92 E. Main, Bicknell.
Thunderbird Restaurant/Facebook
“Ho-made” pie. The sign for this restaurant is priceless. It started when the owner tried to squeeze the whole name onto his sign by shortening the word “home.” At the time, it didn’t have the same sexy connotation. Regardless, the pie is delicious. Try the apple pie with rum sauce. US-89, Mt. Carmel.
Veyo Pies/Facebook
While this list is alphabetical and NOT a ranking, if it was, Veyo Pies would get the award for the Best Pie in the Entire State of Utah. It’s a tiny little shop, in an even tinier little town (Veyo has less than 500 residents). The pies are all completely hand-made, and so good that people drive from all over the state to get them. During holiday season, the shop sells around 100 pies per day. Banana Creme is the favorite.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
