Of everything to come from Florida over the years, we’re probably most proud of Key lime pie (so much that we named it our State Pie). If you love Key lime pie as much as we do, there are a few other Key-lime-inspired treats you need to try:
- Key Lime Donuts from The Donut Experiment, Anna Maria Island
TripAdvisor/Niklas A
TripAdvisor/Hintz1098 You’ll go gaga for this little laboratory that cooks up donuts of every flavor imaginable. You can try donuts made with maple bacon, fruity pebbles, or even sriracha. But our money is on tasty, tangy Key lime pie. 210C Pine Ave Anna Maria, FL 34216
- Chocolate covered frozen key lime pie from Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
TripAdvisor/Janessa D
TripAdvisor/Viennese_Travelbug This is probably the most predictable choice, but still a must-try. We don’t know who started freezing Key lime pie and covering it in chocolate, but we do know that person was a genius. Plus, this longstanding shop is a great place to find just about any Key-lime-inspired product your little heart desires. 200 Elizabeth Street Key West, Florida 33040
- Key Lime Cupcake at Key West Cakes
TripAdvisor/Emanmsma2
TripAdvisor This bakery tucked away from the more touristy parts of the island has been creating some of the best wedding cakes in town for years. You can special order a Key lime cake with Key lime mousse for your big day, or just try one of their heavenly Key lime cupcakes. 1014 White St Key West, FL 33040
- Key Lime Ice Cream from Larry’s Olde Fashioned Ice Cream And Gelato, St. Pete Beach
TripAdvisor/Julie M
TripAdvisor/Glock10mm Nostalgia is in the air at this family-owned old fashioned ice cream parlor that has been a favorite on St. Pete Beach since opening in 1984. Stop in for some Key lime ice cream (one of 80 flavors) or a cake sundae. 6595 Gulf Blvd, St Pete Beach, FL 33706
- Key Lime Muffins from Harriette’s Restaurant, Key Largo
TripAdvisor/hm1bit
TripAdvisor/SEMSMedic This humble little place in Key Largo serves some of the best breakfasts in the Keys, complemented by their delicious homemade muffins. No one can resist these Key lime muffins, perfeclty moist and fluffy, dusted with powdered sugar. 95710 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
- Key Lime Milkshakes from Robert Is Here, Homestead
Facebook/Robert Is Here
Yelp/Courtney L. This fruit stand and farm has become a local landmark, beloved for the selection of exotic fruit. You can always find something new to try here. they’re equally famous for the incredible fresh fruit milkshakes. Key lime fans must try this frosty treat after the stand reopens for the season on November 4th. 19200 SW 344th St, Homestead, FL 33034
- Fried Key Lime Pie at Oltremare Restaurant, Islamorada
Yelp/Benjamin J.
Facebook/Amara Cay Resort Here’s a twist you might have expected to find at the fair, but it’s actually from an upscale restaurant within the Amara Cay Resort. Their deep-fried Key lime pie is served with a side of strawberry compote that complements the over-the-top richness of the dish. 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
- Key Lime Mousse from Blue Gecko Key Lime Pie & Ice Cream Factory, Key West
TripAdvisor/holiday-view23-7-11
TripAdvisor Gluten-free folks will rejoice when they discover the Key lime mousse served in a coconut shell at Blue Gecko. Everyone should be able to enjoy Florida’s favorite dessert, and this is a pretty cool way to replace the crust. 411 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
- Coconut Key Lime Pie from Key Lime Republic, Key West
TripAdivsor
TripAdvisor/Family_Jules1969 The limes are hand-squeezed every morning to make the famous pies and other treats here. The traditional version is good, but you need to try the coconut Key lime pie for a little twist. 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
Can’t get enough of Florida’s favorite dessert? Check out our list of 10 Restaurants That Serve The Best Key Lime Pie In Florida.
TripAdvisor/Niklas A
TripAdvisor/Hintz1098
You’ll go gaga for this little laboratory that cooks up donuts of every flavor imaginable. You can try donuts made with maple bacon, fruity pebbles, or even sriracha. But our money is on tasty, tangy Key lime pie. 210C Pine Ave Anna Maria, FL 34216
TripAdvisor/Janessa D
TripAdvisor/Viennese_Travelbug
This is probably the most predictable choice, but still a must-try. We don’t know who started freezing Key lime pie and covering it in chocolate, but we do know that person was a genius. Plus, this longstanding shop is a great place to find just about any Key-lime-inspired product your little heart desires. 200 Elizabeth Street Key West, Florida 33040
TripAdvisor/Emanmsma2
TripAdvisor
This bakery tucked away from the more touristy parts of the island has been creating some of the best wedding cakes in town for years. You can special order a Key lime cake with Key lime mousse for your big day, or just try one of their heavenly Key lime cupcakes. 1014 White St Key West, FL 33040
TripAdvisor/Julie M
TripAdvisor/Glock10mm
Nostalgia is in the air at this family-owned old fashioned ice cream parlor that has been a favorite on St. Pete Beach since opening in 1984. Stop in for some Key lime ice cream (one of 80 flavors) or a cake sundae. 6595 Gulf Blvd, St Pete Beach, FL 33706
TripAdvisor/hm1bit
TripAdvisor/SEMSMedic
This humble little place in Key Largo serves some of the best breakfasts in the Keys, complemented by their delicious homemade muffins. No one can resist these Key lime muffins, perfeclty moist and fluffy, dusted with powdered sugar. 95710 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Facebook/Robert Is Here
Yelp/Courtney L.
This fruit stand and farm has become a local landmark, beloved for the selection of exotic fruit. You can always find something new to try here. they’re equally famous for the incredible fresh fruit milkshakes. Key lime fans must try this frosty treat after the stand reopens for the season on November 4th. 19200 SW 344th St, Homestead, FL 33034
Yelp/Benjamin J.
Facebook/Amara Cay Resort
Here’s a twist you might have expected to find at the fair, but it’s actually from an upscale restaurant within the Amara Cay Resort. Their deep-fried Key lime pie is served with a side of strawberry compote that complements the over-the-top richness of the dish. 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
TripAdvisor/holiday-view23-7-11
Gluten-free folks will rejoice when they discover the Key lime mousse served in a coconut shell at Blue Gecko. Everyone should be able to enjoy Florida’s favorite dessert, and this is a pretty cool way to replace the crust. 411 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
TripAdivsor
TripAdvisor/Family_Jules1969
The limes are hand-squeezed every morning to make the famous pies and other treats here. The traditional version is good, but you need to try the coconut Key lime pie for a little twist. 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
