Kelis’ milkshake might bring all the boys to the yard, but this milkshake bar is bringing ice cream lovers straight to Buffalo – which, we would argue, is way better. There are several great ice cream spots to check out in the 716, but if you have to pick just one, we recommend getting your freak on at this incredible milkshake bar!
If you couldn’t guess, Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream is located on Hertel Avenue.
Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream - Facebook You’ll find Buffalo’s best milkshakes at 1488 Hertel Avenue.
Their milkshakes are “Freak”-ing delicious.
Kiarra M. - Yelp Dubbed as “Freak Shakes,” this Buffalo milkshake bar serves up the most amazing milkshakes. Each shake comes in its own giant mug, garnished with a mountain toppings (and requiring at least a small stack of napkins).
They say it’s your birthday…
Jane B. - Yelp Live every day like it’s your birthday with the “Cake” Freak Shake: Vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and a cupcake on top! It’s a sugar overload in the best possible way.
If you’ve got ears, say “Cheers!”
Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream - Facebook (Sorry for the Mickey Mouse Clubhouse reference, we couldn’t help ourselves.) One of the most popular Freak Shakes at Hertel Ave Poutine & Cream is “The Chocolate Mouse.” Peanut butter lovers go nuts (pun intended) for this peanut butter-chocolate ice cream with Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter cups on top, drizzled with chocolate and caramel sauce. Sign me up!
Choose a topping, any topping!
Erin H. - Yelp Along with their Freak Shakes, this Buffalo milkshake bar also serves up traditional shakes and ice cream cones with plenty of topics to choose from. You can create your own frozen masterpiece!
Get your buns over here to try their Creamy Buns!
Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream - Facebook Creamy WHATS? Creamy Buns are like donut paninis with ice cream in the center, and there are tons of flavors to try! The most unique is probably the “Breakfast” Creamy Bun: vanilla ice cream with Captain Crunch cereal!
“Do you want fries with that shake?”
Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream - Facebook At Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream, the answer to the age-old question should always be a resounding, “YES!” Their poutine is half of the restaurant’s namesake, after all.
This Buffalo milkshake bar is open Monday through Saturday from 11:30AM to midnight, and Sundays from 11:30 AM to 11 PM. We’re already making plans to get our hands on the “Cookie Monster.”
Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream - Facebook
You’ll find Buffalo’s best milkshakes at 1488 Hertel Avenue.
Kiarra M. - Yelp
Dubbed as “Freak Shakes,” this Buffalo milkshake bar serves up the most amazing milkshakes. Each shake comes in its own giant mug, garnished with a mountain toppings (and requiring at least a small stack of napkins).
Jane B. - Yelp
Live every day like it’s your birthday with the “Cake” Freak Shake: Vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, and a cupcake on top! It’s a sugar overload in the best possible way.
(Sorry for the Mickey Mouse Clubhouse reference, we couldn’t help ourselves.) One of the most popular Freak Shakes at Hertel Ave Poutine & Cream is “The Chocolate Mouse.” Peanut butter lovers go nuts (pun intended) for this peanut butter-chocolate ice cream with Reese’s Pieces and peanut butter cups on top, drizzled with chocolate and caramel sauce. Sign me up!
Erin H. - Yelp
Along with their Freak Shakes, this Buffalo milkshake bar also serves up traditional shakes and ice cream cones with plenty of topics to choose from. You can create your own frozen masterpiece!
Creamy WHATS? Creamy Buns are like donut paninis with ice cream in the center, and there are tons of flavors to try! The most unique is probably the “Breakfast” Creamy Bun: vanilla ice cream with Captain Crunch cereal!
At Hertel Ave Poutine and Cream, the answer to the age-old question should always be a resounding, “YES!” Their poutine is half of the restaurant’s namesake, after all.
If you’ve been to Poutine & Cream already, let us know what your favorite flavor Freak Shake is in the comments! If not, tell us what you’re dying to try!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
