Pittsburghers have no shortage of pizzerias to satisfy those late night pizza cravings. With so many mouthwatering pizzas available in Pittsburgh, however, deciding where to order from promises a delicious challenge. Here is the ultimate pizza bucket list for Pittsburgh that will most likely make your mouth water.
- Vincent’s Pizza Park – 998 Ardmore Boulevard, Pittsburgh, PA 15221
Facebook/Vincent’s Pizza Park
Yelp/Trey S. Order the popular Vinnie Pie to experience what many Pittsburghers consider the best pizza in the Burgh. Go for the plain or add as many toppings - pineapple, bacon, or pepperoni - as you like. Vincent’s Pizza also offers hearty salads to pair with your pizza.
- Shelly Pie – 912 Penn Avenue, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
Facebook/Shelly Pie Pizza
Yelp/Paul C. Dine in or take out a scrumptious pizza at Shelly Pie. The menu, which offers regular and white pizza, features your choice of traditional or premium toppings, such as ricotta cheese, sauteed banana peppers, spinach, or meatballs.
- Mineo’s Pizza – 2128 Murray Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
Yelp/Whitley S.
Yelp/T.M. Treat yourself to one of Pittsburgh’s favorite pizzas at Mineo’s Pizza in Squirrel Hill or Mount Lebanon. Browse the menu that features traditional hand tossed pizza, white hand tossed pizza, gluten-free pizza, and Sicilian pizza. Mineo’s offers pizzas by the slice or by the pie.
- Beto’s Pizza – 1473 Banksville Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15216
Yelp/Chi E.
Yelp/Stacie C. Indulge in a 60 year Pittsburgh tradition when you visit Beto’s Pizza and Restaurant. Unlike most pizzerias, Beto’s serves pizza by the cut only, adding the toppings after the pizza itself has been cooked to preserve the flavors of the cheese and other toppings. Beto’s also sells trays of individual cuts.
- Nick’s Pizza – 329 Mt. Lebanon Boulevard, Pittsburgh, PA 15234
Yelp/Nick’s Pizza
Yelp/Nick’s Pizza Sit back and wait for your order from Nick’s Pizza to arrive, dine-in, or take out from one of Pittsburgh’s favorite pizzerias. Choose from traditional or gourmet - white, Hawaiian, meat lovers, or supreme - pizza. Nick’s Pizza also serves a massive 20 inch pie called the Big Wheel.
- Sir Pizza – 320 Sewickley Oakmont Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15237
Yelp/Jennifer B.
Yelp/Alan B. Enjoy a relaxing meal or order out with Sir Pizza, a Pittsburgh tradition since 1975. Boasting a delicious crust and served in squares, Sir Pizza features traditional pizza as well as such specialty pizzas as white pizza, the veggie feast pizza, and the royal feast pizza.
- Donte’s Pizzeria – 6409 Brownsville Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15236
Facebook/Donte’s Pizzeria
Facebook/Donte’s Pizzeria A Pittsburgh staple for 11 years, Donte’s Pizza serves both pizza slices and whole pies. Browse the menu that boasts such specialty pizzas as breakfast pizza, Italian-style pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, and deep dish pizza.
- Della Sala’s – 5527 Verona Road, Verona, PA 15147
Yelp/Gina R. Della Sala’s in Verona has been serving some of the city’s most popular Sicilian pizza - and only Sicilian pizza. Housed in a white garage, Della Sala’s features a unique, buttery crust and is sliced into square cuts.
- Fiori’s Pizzaria – 103 Capital Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15226
Yelp/Fiori’s Pizzaria
Yelp/Lee B. Order a slice or a whole pizza pie when you visit Fiori’s Pizzaria, which serves both traditional and specialty pizzas. Add your favorite toppings, including such gourmet toppings as meatballs, steak, shrimp, or hot sausage links. Traditional toppings are also available.
- Pizza Italia – 4512 Liberty Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15224
Facebook/Pizza Italia
Yelp/Tiffany N. Add Pizza Italia, which serves both traditional and white pizza, to your pizza bucket list. The Bloomfield pizzeria also offers Sicilian pizza by the slice. Add extra cheese to your pie or choose your favorite traditional toppings, such as pepperoni, mushrooms, hot peppers, and broccoli.
Which pizza places do you think also belong on the ultimate pizza place for Pittsburgh? Do you think any of these pizzerias should be on the list?
Facebook/Vincent’s Pizza Park
Yelp/Trey S.
Order the popular Vinnie Pie to experience what many Pittsburghers consider the best pizza in the Burgh. Go for the plain or add as many toppings - pineapple, bacon, or pepperoni - as you like. Vincent’s Pizza also offers hearty salads to pair with your pizza.
Facebook/Shelly Pie Pizza
Yelp/Paul C.
Dine in or take out a scrumptious pizza at Shelly Pie. The menu, which offers regular and white pizza, features your choice of traditional or premium toppings, such as ricotta cheese, sauteed banana peppers, spinach, or meatballs.
Yelp/Whitley S.
Yelp/T.M.
Treat yourself to one of Pittsburgh’s favorite pizzas at Mineo’s Pizza in Squirrel Hill or Mount Lebanon. Browse the menu that features traditional hand tossed pizza, white hand tossed pizza, gluten-free pizza, and Sicilian pizza. Mineo’s offers pizzas by the slice or by the pie.
Yelp/Chi E.
Yelp/Stacie C.
Indulge in a 60 year Pittsburgh tradition when you visit Beto’s Pizza and Restaurant. Unlike most pizzerias, Beto’s serves pizza by the cut only, adding the toppings after the pizza itself has been cooked to preserve the flavors of the cheese and other toppings. Beto’s also sells trays of individual cuts.
Yelp/Nick’s Pizza
Sit back and wait for your order from Nick’s Pizza to arrive, dine-in, or take out from one of Pittsburgh’s favorite pizzerias. Choose from traditional or gourmet - white, Hawaiian, meat lovers, or supreme - pizza. Nick’s Pizza also serves a massive 20 inch pie called the Big Wheel.
Yelp/Jennifer B.
Yelp/Alan B.
Enjoy a relaxing meal or order out with Sir Pizza, a Pittsburgh tradition since 1975. Boasting a delicious crust and served in squares, Sir Pizza features traditional pizza as well as such specialty pizzas as white pizza, the veggie feast pizza, and the royal feast pizza.
Facebook/Donte’s Pizzeria
A Pittsburgh staple for 11 years, Donte’s Pizza serves both pizza slices and whole pies. Browse the menu that boasts such specialty pizzas as breakfast pizza, Italian-style pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, and deep dish pizza.
Yelp/Gina R.
Della Sala’s in Verona has been serving some of the city’s most popular Sicilian pizza - and only Sicilian pizza. Housed in a white garage, Della Sala’s features a unique, buttery crust and is sliced into square cuts.
Yelp/Fiori’s Pizzaria
Yelp/Lee B.
Order a slice or a whole pizza pie when you visit Fiori’s Pizzaria, which serves both traditional and specialty pizzas. Add your favorite toppings, including such gourmet toppings as meatballs, steak, shrimp, or hot sausage links. Traditional toppings are also available.
Facebook/Pizza Italia
Yelp/Tiffany N.
Add Pizza Italia, which serves both traditional and white pizza, to your pizza bucket list. The Bloomfield pizzeria also offers Sicilian pizza by the slice. Add extra cheese to your pie or choose your favorite traditional toppings, such as pepperoni, mushrooms, hot peppers, and broccoli.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 998 Ardmore Boulevard, Pittsburgh, PA 15221Address: 912 Penn Avenue, Turtle Creek, PA 15145Address: 1473 Banksville Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15216Address: 329 Mt. Lebanon Boulevard, Pittsburgh, PA 15234Address: 320 Sewickley Oakmont Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15237Address: 6409 Brownsville Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15236Address: 5527 Verona Road, Verona, PA 15147Address: 103 Capital Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15226Address: 4512 Liberty Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15224Address: 2128 Murray Avenue, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
