The Indiana tenderloin isn’t just a sandwich. For many, it’s a bit of a legend. Many Hoosiers spend years trying to find the perfect tenderloin, and there are many disagreements over which restaurant makes the best sandwich.
Luckily, you no longer have to choose a favorite since Indiana now has an official tenderloin trail spanning across Hamilton County – and you need to check it out before the specials end! Every Tuesday until July 25th, these 50 plus restaurants are offering great specials on Indiana’s favorite sandwich. Here’s a look at seven awesome restaurants below:
- Alexander’s on the Square - Noblesville
Suzanne S./Yelp
Leslie W./Yelp If you like a masive tenderloin, you’ll definitely want to check out Alexander’s on the Square. Not only is their tenderloin perfectly seasoned and breaded, but you can also get it with a side of their famous ice cream. Find them at 864 Logan St, Noblesville, IN 46060.
- Erika’s Place - Cicero
TripAdvisor
Chris G./TripAdvisor For a classic tenderloin in a friendly, laid back setting, you have to check out Erika’s place. They’re well known locally for their awesome comfort food, but nothing tops their famous tenderloin sandwich. Find them at 40 W Jackson St, Cicero, IN 46034.
- Grand Junction Brewing Company - Westfield
Yelp
Grand Junction Brewing Co/Facebok This lively pub cooks up a mean tenderloin and sometimes breaks from tradition by serving it under a bed of gravy topped with a fried egg. Try it out at 110 S Union St, Westfield, Indiana.
- C.R. Hero’s Family Pub - Fishers
Stephanie B./Yelp
John C./Yelp This family friendly pub is well known for their epic tenderloin sandwich dubbed, “The Hoosier Daddy.” Get it with a tasty side of sweet potato fries for a real treat. Find them at 10570 E 96th St Fishers, IN 46037.
- Woody’s Library Restaurant - Carmel
Jon A,/Yelp
Marshall B./TripAdvisor This converted library restaurant serves up some awesome home cooking, including the beloved tenderloin sandwich. Dine inside or out at this classic Indiana restaurant. Find it at 40 E Main St, Carmel, IN 46032.
- Courtney’s Kitchen - Noblesville
Chissy C./Yelp
Chrissy C./Yelp Courtney’s Kitchen is a hidden gem in Noblesville that serves up incredible traditional cuisine. Their flat, breaded tenderloin is packed full of flavor (and don’t worry - you can order a petite version if you’re not up to the challenge). Find them at 654 Logan St Noblesville, IN 46060.
- Sahm’s Bar and Grill - Fishers
Dede S./Yelp
Libby B./Yelp Sahm’s is well known for their incredible tenderloin, served on a freshly toasted bun. Be sure to try it with their famous dill slaw or or fresh cut french fries. Find them at 7870 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037.
You can find a full list of the restaurants along the tenderloin trail here. For some of the best tenderloin restaurants across the Hoosier state, check out this article.
Suzanne S./Yelp
Leslie W./Yelp
If you like a masive tenderloin, you’ll definitely want to check out Alexander’s on the Square. Not only is their tenderloin perfectly seasoned and breaded, but you can also get it with a side of their famous ice cream. Find them at 864 Logan St, Noblesville, IN 46060.
TripAdvisor
Chris G./TripAdvisor
For a classic tenderloin in a friendly, laid back setting, you have to check out Erika’s place. They’re well known locally for their awesome comfort food, but nothing tops their famous tenderloin sandwich. Find them at 40 W Jackson St, Cicero, IN 46034.
Yelp
Grand Junction Brewing Co/Facebok
This lively pub cooks up a mean tenderloin and sometimes breaks from tradition by serving it under a bed of gravy topped with a fried egg. Try it out at 110 S Union St, Westfield, Indiana.
Stephanie B./Yelp
John C./Yelp
This family friendly pub is well known for their epic tenderloin sandwich dubbed, “The Hoosier Daddy.” Get it with a tasty side of sweet potato fries for a real treat. Find them at 10570 E 96th St Fishers, IN 46037.
Jon A,/Yelp
Marshall B./TripAdvisor
This converted library restaurant serves up some awesome home cooking, including the beloved tenderloin sandwich. Dine inside or out at this classic Indiana restaurant. Find it at 40 E Main St, Carmel, IN 46032.
Chissy C./Yelp
Chrissy C./Yelp
Courtney’s Kitchen is a hidden gem in Noblesville that serves up incredible traditional cuisine. Their flat, breaded tenderloin is packed full of flavor (and don’t worry - you can order a petite version if you’re not up to the challenge). Find them at 654 Logan St Noblesville, IN 46060.
Dede S./Yelp
Libby B./Yelp
Sahm’s is well known for their incredible tenderloin, served on a freshly toasted bun. Be sure to try it with their famous dill slaw or or fresh cut french fries. Find them at 7870 E 96th St, Fishers, IN 46037.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
