Pie is a New Jersey staple year-round, especially with all the fresh fruit in the Garden State. Still, the holidays are approaching and that means the official start of pie season. What makes a more delectable Thanksgiving dessert? If you’re craving an indulgent slice, you’re in luck. It isn’t hard to find a good pie in New Jersey, but these are some of the best (in no particular order).
- Penza’s Pies, Hammonton
Facebook/PenzasPies
Facebook/PenzasPie Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Cafe offers a sizable selection of sweet and savory pies, seasonally. Thanksgiving offerings include Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Peach Ricotta, Apple Blueberry, and over a dozen other delectable options.
- The Pie Store, Montclair
Facebook/ThePieStore
Facebook/ThePieStore This British bakery offers traditional desserts and goodies from the UK. Alongside specialty chocolates and scones, you will find incredible Key Lime and Banana Toffee pies.
- The Macaroon Shop, Avon By The Sea
Facebook/TheMacaroonShop
Facebook/TheMacaronShop Though it may be known for its Macaroons, this bakery offers a variety of sweet treats. The custom cakes are gorgeous and the pies are perfectly sized, ranging from 6" - 10". The Lemon Meringue is a favorite.
- Johnson’s Corner Farm, Medford
Facebook/Johnson’s Corner Farm
Facebook/JohnsonsCornerFarm This family favorite destination offers so much more than pumpkin picking and hayrides. Enjoy some of the freshest pie around, with 5 different kinds of apple pie to choose from. There is a pie tasting party today (11/14-11/15), to support charity. Upcoming events include holiday hayrides and a classic car show.
- Rosaline’s Farm & Bakery, Augusta
Facebook/RosalinesFarmAndBakery
Facebook/RosalinesFarmAndBakery Enjoy soups, sandwiches and scrumptious pies. Apple Crumb is a popular pick, and they even offer a gluten-free Coconut Custard Meringue.
- Homestead Farm Market, Lambertville
Facebook/HomesteadFarmMarket
Facebook/HomesteadFarmMarket This local farmer’s market may not seem like much on the outside, but they offer a great selection of fresh fruits, veggies, and dairy products. The Pumpkin Pie is a seasonal favorite, but the Peachberry and Rhubarb Berry are also flavorful picks.
- Emery’s Berry Patch, New Egypt
Yelp/Simon C.
Yelp/Tara T. A major producer of blueberries in the state, you have to try their Blueberry Pies. Other standout stars include the Trifecta (Blueberries, Cherries + Peaches) and Maple Apple.
- Mara’s Cafe & Bakery, Denville
Facebook/MarasDesserts
Facebook/MarasDesserts My oh my, this is some good pie! Enjoy an extensive selection of foods, desserts and pies at this popular shop. The Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie is a personal favorite, but Pecan, Peach, and Three Nut Cranberry are all great choices.
- Ye Olde Pie Shoppe, Little Silver
Facebook/YeOldePieShoppe
Facebook/YeOldePieShoppe The custom cakes are so impeccably crafted, you might forget that they make anything else. Try the Cranberry-Apple Pie or one of the Cookie Pies.
- Bertuzzi’s Farm Market, Milmay
Yelp/Joy G.
Yelp/Joy G. This South Jersey farmer’s market features a greenhouse and bakery. There are a variety of pies to choose from, but the Caramel Apple Walnut is probably the most popular.
- Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory, Englewood
Facebook/MrTodsPieFactory
Facebook/MrTodsPieFactory Mr. Tod’s pies are out of this world! Country Living Magazine and Oprah named Mr. Tod’s one of the best mail order pie companies in America and the bakery has been featured in the New York Times, on The Today Show, ABC, and CNBC. Locations in Montclair and South Bound Brook are coming soon. The Banana Cream and Apple are popular picks.
- Battleview Orchards, Freehold
Facebook/Battleview Orchards
Facebook/Battleview Orchards Besides seasonal pick-your-own fruit opportunities, the desserts here are just delightful. Enjoy Coconut Custard, Lemon Crunch, Pecan, Pumpkin, and Sweet Potato this season; wait for the summer to score some amazing Pina Colada Pie!
Have you enjoyed a slice of pie at any of these places? Which is your favorite flavor? What other great places to get pie in New Jersey would you recommend?
Facebook/PenzasPies
Facebook/PenzasPie
Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Cafe offers a sizable selection of sweet and savory pies, seasonally. Thanksgiving offerings include Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Peach Ricotta, Apple Blueberry, and over a dozen other delectable options.
Facebook/ThePieStore
This British bakery offers traditional desserts and goodies from the UK. Alongside specialty chocolates and scones, you will find incredible Key Lime and Banana Toffee pies.
Facebook/TheMacaroonShop
Facebook/TheMacaronShop
Though it may be known for its Macaroons, this bakery offers a variety of sweet treats. The custom cakes are gorgeous and the pies are perfectly sized, ranging from 6" - 10". The Lemon Meringue is a favorite.
Facebook/Johnson’s Corner Farm
Facebook/JohnsonsCornerFarm
This family favorite destination offers so much more than pumpkin picking and hayrides. Enjoy some of the freshest pie around, with 5 different kinds of apple pie to choose from. There is a pie tasting party today (11/14-11/15), to support charity. Upcoming events include holiday hayrides and a classic car show.
Facebook/RosalinesFarmAndBakery
Enjoy soups, sandwiches and scrumptious pies. Apple Crumb is a popular pick, and they even offer a gluten-free Coconut Custard Meringue.
Facebook/HomesteadFarmMarket
This local farmer’s market may not seem like much on the outside, but they offer a great selection of fresh fruits, veggies, and dairy products. The Pumpkin Pie is a seasonal favorite, but the Peachberry and Rhubarb Berry are also flavorful picks.
Yelp/Simon C.
Yelp/Tara T.
A major producer of blueberries in the state, you have to try their Blueberry Pies. Other standout stars include the Trifecta (Blueberries, Cherries + Peaches) and Maple Apple.
Facebook/MarasDesserts
My oh my, this is some good pie! Enjoy an extensive selection of foods, desserts and pies at this popular shop. The Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie is a personal favorite, but Pecan, Peach, and Three Nut Cranberry are all great choices.
Facebook/YeOldePieShoppe
The custom cakes are so impeccably crafted, you might forget that they make anything else. Try the Cranberry-Apple Pie or one of the Cookie Pies.
Yelp/Joy G.
This South Jersey farmer’s market features a greenhouse and bakery. There are a variety of pies to choose from, but the Caramel Apple Walnut is probably the most popular.
Facebook/MrTodsPieFactory
Mr. Tod’s pies are out of this world! Country Living Magazine and Oprah named Mr. Tod’s one of the best mail order pie companies in America and the bakery has been featured in the New York Times, on The Today Show, ABC, and CNBC. Locations in Montclair and South Bound Brook are coming soon. The Banana Cream and Apple are popular picks.
Facebook/Battleview Orchards
Besides seasonal pick-your-own fruit opportunities, the desserts here are just delightful. Enjoy Coconut Custard, Lemon Crunch, Pecan, Pumpkin, and Sweet Potato this season; wait for the summer to score some amazing Pina Colada Pie!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
