The number of sweltering days ahead of us may be growing fewer, but we’re still clinging on to every inch of summer that we have left. One of the most enjoyable ways to take your mind off of the fact that this wonderful season is coming to a close, is to set up shop with a tasty ice cream treat.
If you’ve grown tired of chasing down the neighborhood ice cream truck or are just looking to check out someplace new, then you’re in luck. There’s no better place to get your fix for summer desserts than this tiny shop in New York that serves ice cream sandwiches:
Right in Midtown, you’ll find this tiny but vibrant shop that holds the key to your happiness.
Jeff L./Yelp New York City is known for showing visitors things that they would’ve never dreamed of, especially when it comes to food. There are so many mind-blowing ice cream shops in the Big Apple, narrowing it down to one place can prove to be difficult. We’re truly spoiled.
Walk through the doors of Holey Cream and you’ll immediately see what’s pictured below, painted up on the wall.
Akvile H./Yelp
Combining the best of both world’s, Holey Cream allows you to create your own mouthwatering Donut Ice Cream Sandwich!
Sandy Y./Yelp
Jeenee Y./Yelp Once again, we are so spoiled. The most difficult part of this trip will be deciding all of your flavors and toppings. Pictured above, you can see the slice of heaven we like to refer to as the Toppings Bar.
Take it all in, appreciate the amazing donut and ice cream combination that has been brought to real life!
Courtney I./Yelp
ilgibboviaggiatore/TripAdvisor From M&M’s to Fruit Loops, the topping choices will appeal to any and every sweet tooth that walks in through the door.
The best advice we can give to anyone making their first visit to this shop, is to arrive on a very empty stomach.
Ian H./Yelp We assure you, you’ll want every inch and corner of your stomach available to tackle these masterful desserts. It also never hurts to bring a friend along with you so that you can both try different flavors and toppings, because you’ll for obvious reasons have a hard time narrowing things down to one choice.
The homemade ice cream’s are packed with creamy flavor that will have you sounding like the happiest broken record.
Phil H./Yelp Quickly captivated by the fresh smells within this shop, you’ll have a hard time stopping yourself from repeatedly giving this place compliments. Another major problem you’ll stumble upon while ordering at Holey Cream, picking your ice cream flavor. From Outrageous Long Island Raspberry Rhapsody to Midnight Cookies and Cream, your eyes will quickly grow bigger than your stomach.
If for some reason you find yourself not wanting to combine your donut with ice cream, you can try one of their amazing donuts on its own!
Jeenee Y./Yelp Holey Cream offers a variety of fresh donuts that you only wish you could’ve gotten your hands on as a child, fulfilling every outrageous dessert dream you ever had. From Gummie Bear Delight to Nutella and Rainbow Sprinkles, you’ll fall in love with these donuts.
While the shop is known for being one of the first places to have the Donut Ice Cream Sandwich, it’s also known for many other delicious desserts.
Jed S./Yelp Pictured above, you can see the tasty Reeses Brownie, a popular order at Holey Cream. Alongside a variety of brownies, you can also get jumbo cookies, sundaes, frozen yogurt, smoothies and more here! So basically, everything you’ve ever desired.
Another perk to this tiny shop? They stay open late and deliver.
John B./Yelp
Robyn W./Yelp Open everyday from 12:30PM to 12:30AM, you’ll easily be able to find time for one of these heavenly desserts on a hot summer day.
Click here, to view Holey Cream’s website where you can see their menu and order for delivery!
So, who’s ready to cross off the Donut Ice Cream Sandwich from their Summer 2016 bucket list?
Brian K M./Yelp Would it be wrong to eat a Donut Ice Cream Sandwich every day? Simply asking for a friend.
How to get here: 796 9th Avenue New York, NY 10019 Between 52nd Street and 53rd Street
If you’re looking to discover other other amazing places to grab dessert in our state, check out these 14 Ice Cream Shops In New York That Will Make Your Sweet Tooth Go Crazy!
Jeff L./Yelp
New York City is known for showing visitors things that they would’ve never dreamed of, especially when it comes to food. There are so many mind-blowing ice cream shops in the Big Apple, narrowing it down to one place can prove to be difficult. We’re truly spoiled.
Akvile H./Yelp
Sandy Y./Yelp
Jeenee Y./Yelp
Once again, we are so spoiled. The most difficult part of this trip will be deciding all of your flavors and toppings. Pictured above, you can see the slice of heaven we like to refer to as the Toppings Bar.
Courtney I./Yelp
ilgibboviaggiatore/TripAdvisor
From M&M’s to Fruit Loops, the topping choices will appeal to any and every sweet tooth that walks in through the door.
Ian H./Yelp
We assure you, you’ll want every inch and corner of your stomach available to tackle these masterful desserts. It also never hurts to bring a friend along with you so that you can both try different flavors and toppings, because you’ll for obvious reasons have a hard time narrowing things down to one choice.
Phil H./Yelp
Quickly captivated by the fresh smells within this shop, you’ll have a hard time stopping yourself from repeatedly giving this place compliments. Another major problem you’ll stumble upon while ordering at Holey Cream, picking your ice cream flavor. From Outrageous Long Island Raspberry Rhapsody to Midnight Cookies and Cream, your eyes will quickly grow bigger than your stomach.
Holey Cream offers a variety of fresh donuts that you only wish you could’ve gotten your hands on as a child, fulfilling every outrageous dessert dream you ever had. From Gummie Bear Delight to Nutella and Rainbow Sprinkles, you’ll fall in love with these donuts.
Jed S./Yelp
Pictured above, you can see the tasty Reeses Brownie, a popular order at Holey Cream. Alongside a variety of brownies, you can also get jumbo cookies, sundaes, frozen yogurt, smoothies and more here! So basically, everything you’ve ever desired.
John B./Yelp
Robyn W./Yelp
Open everyday from 12:30PM to 12:30AM, you’ll easily be able to find time for one of these heavenly desserts on a hot summer day.
Click here, to view Holey Cream’s website where you can see their menu and order for delivery!
Brian K M./Yelp
Would it be wrong to eat a Donut Ice Cream Sandwich every day? Simply asking for a friend.
How to get here: 796 9th Avenue New York, NY 10019 Between 52nd Street and 53rd Street
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
